Sunday, October 20, 2013

     Maureen Johnson's article "Yes, teen fiction can be dark – but it shows teenagers they aren't alone" introduces  the idea that banned books are often the books that show readers they are not alone and can get through tough situations. She goes on to say that just because authors are writing about things like rape and self harm, doesn't mean that it give the reader the idea to do that, so all the book is doing is either helping someone that is going through the same situation or is teaching someone about the real world. "There isn't a YA writer alive who is out writing books to corrupt youth. No one writing about self-harm is teaching how to self-harm. No one writing about rape is providing instructions on how to rape or how to be raped. I know this seems a ridiculously obvious point, but this is the argument that comes up again and again." Maureen ends her article by saying that YA fiction really helps readers by showing them that they aren't alone and that everything they're going through is normal.

     In Maureen Johnson's article, I noticed some craft moves that helped make her side of the story more believable. One craft move I picked up on was that she used a ton of loaded words like ''grossly underestimate'', "completely ignores", and "saves someone's life" to evoke emotion. One more example of a craft move that she uses is she creates imagery by comparing situations in your mind and saying "All food is Italian food, and I don't like Italian Food, so it should not exist. The fact that it does exist means the food industry is 
forcing it on my children!" these craft moves allow readers to have feelings about YA fiction and think about what they are reading.There isn't a YA writer alive who is out writing books to corrupt youth. 

     On a personal level, I agree completely with Maureen 
Johnson's article. I do not think that young adult fiction books should be banned because they help readers through tough situations and show them that they aren't alone. A certain line that stood out to me was "There isn't a YA writer alive who is out writing books to corrupt youth." because it showed me that all authors really want to do is help readers by sending a message through their writing."if subjects like these are in YA books, it's to show that they are real, they have happened to others, and they can be survived." 

     

3 comments:

  1. Hola maya! in your summary you bring up a lot of interesting points about how reading YA books about dark subjects doesn't encourage teens to imitate these behaviors and in some cases help teens through them. I liked how you tied that quote in the beginning to you opinion paragraph at the end. it really brings the whole piece together. Extraordinary work maya, it was truly scrumptious.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey there, first of all I love your background of your blog, and second your reading response is really great. One visible detail i noticed was how you highlighted the quotes even though its small it makes them stand out. Also I noticed how at the end of every quote you added what you feel about the quote. as Jolene said, Extraordinary work maya :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree with all of your points!!! This article is one of the strongest I have read about young adult fiction and you did a gr8 job summarizing it and explaining the author's reasoning. And you know I love that background!! (and the URL haha) Good job. -Your Friendly Neighbor Pamela

    ReplyDelete